128 CCW states to spend two years drafting autonomous weapons rules – binding status left open
The 128 parties to the UN Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) agreed in Geneva to begin drafting an instrument on lethal autonomous weapons over the next two years. Whether it will be legally binding remains open, because the consensus rule gave opponents a veto.
Talks in Geneva ran through the night and ended on the morning of Saturday 21 November. They dealt with weapons systems that, once activated, select and strike a target without human intervention.
The conference chair, Swiss diplomat Julien Thöni, said the countries had ‘agreed to launch the elaboration of an international instrument’, DW reported. The work is due to take place over the next two years. What the decision leaves out is crucial. DW and Spiegel, both citing dpa and Reuters, reported that government experts will propose only by 2028 whether the outcome will be a legally binding treaty.
The decision-making rule explains the result. In the CCW every party must approve a decision, so a small group can block the will of the majority. Heise wrote that Russia’s opposition amounted in practice to a veto. The United States, Britain, Israel and Belarus also had reservations about committing to a binding treaty. NPR reported that the US proposed spending five years considering voluntary guidelines.
Sources differ on how many countries backed binding rules. Heise puts the figure at 98 states, and Business Upturn, citing Reuters, at about 100. The campaign network Stop Killer Robots said more than 95 states supported a treaty.
Before the conference, Germany had pushed for a binding treaty banning fully autonomous weapons, Heise and DW reported. During the talks, however, Germany signalled that it was ready to compromise so as not to jeopardise consensus, Heise wrote. The Guardian, as summarised by The Boston Report, reported that Germany and France favoured a non-binding agreement.
In a statement carried by AFP, Stop Killer Robots said: ‘In the final hours, a small number of states weakened the mandate introducing uncertainty about the legal status of the final document.’ UN disarmament chief Izumi Nakamitsu told AFP that completing the work within two years would be demanding. She said a binding outcome was still possible.
Because of the compromise, weapons that can use artificial intelligence to make life-and-death decisions will remain unregulated for at least two years, NPR reported. Amnesty International and Magnus Lovold of Lex International propose pursuing a binding treaty outside the CCW’s consensus procedure.