Canadian publishers’ copyright lawsuit against OpenAI to be heard in Ontario
The Court of Appeal for Ontario has dismissed OpenAI’s appeal, so Canadian news publishers’ lawsuit over ChatGPT’s training data can proceed in Ontario. The ruling concerns only where the case is heard, not whether OpenAI infringed copyright.
OpenAI has lost a dispute over which country should hear a lawsuit brought against it by Canadian media outlets. The Canadian Press news agency, itself one of the plaintiffs, reported the ruling on Saturday on the TorontoToday website.
The Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed OpenAI’s appeal on Friday 13 November. It is a provincial court in Ontario, not the Supreme Court of Canada. The three-judge panel was unanimous, according to Bars Across, a legal news site.
The Canadian Press, Torstar, The Globe and Mail, Postmedia and CBC/Radio-Canada were among the publishers that filed the lawsuit in November 2024. They allege that OpenAI copied their articles without permission, used them as training data for its GPT models and profited from them without paying. The suit also alleges that OpenAI circumvented technical protection measures and breached the websites’ terms of use, Bars Across reported. The plaintiffs seek, among other things, a permanent injunction and damages or, alternatively, statutory damages of 20,000 Canadian dollars per work. None of the allegations has been proven.
Why the case stays in Canada
OpenAI argued that its conduct took place abroad and asked for the case to be heard in the United States. Justice Jessica Kimmel of the Ontario Superior Court largely rejected that request on 7 November 2025. Bars Across reported that Kimmel found the plaintiffs had sufficiently shown that three OpenAI operating companies are connected to Ontario through their business, alleged local acts and the websites’ terms of use. The action continues against three holding companies as a claim for unjust enrichment. It was stayed against four other OpenAI companies because their role in the conduct had not been shown.
The Court of Appeal found that OpenAI had put forward no evidence that a Canadian judgment would conflict with US law and so complicate enforcement, The Canadian Press reported. The ruling also said the judge had considered that the functioning of the Canadian justice system favoured letting Canadian creators sue foreign companies for breaching Canadian law.
The copyright question remains open
The ruling decides only where the remaining claims will be heard. Still unresolved, Bars Across wrote, are how far Canadian copyright law reaches beyond the country’s borders and how the use of material in AI development is treated.
The Canadian Press said this is the first Canadian lawsuit over the use of copyrighted material to train generative AI. This year, Postmedia, Torstar, The Globe and Mail and The Canadian Press filed a separate lawsuit against Anthropic. The federal government has not said it plans to reform copyright law, the agency reported.