ChatGPT link tag found in documents from 298 federal court cases, study says
HumanizeMy.ai, a service that writes and detects AI text, found the tag ChatGPT adds to links in 298 US federal court cases and 133 SEC filings. The tag shows only that a link was copied from a ChatGPT answer.
When ChatGPT gives a user a link, it adds the string utm_source=chatgpt.com to the end of the URL. Tracking tags like this tell the destination site where a visitor came from. Users can remove the tag by hand, but in a link pasted into a document it often goes unnoticed.
HumanizeMy.ai, a service that writes and detects AI text, searched six public archives for the tag and opened every hit to verify it. LawSites, Bob Ambrogi’s legal technology blog, reported the study on 17 November. Pivot News notes that the findings have not been independently verified.
The court documents came from the Free Law Project’s RECAP archive. The tag appeared in 298 cases in 71 courts, most often in the complaint, the document that starts a case. Nearly 40 per cent of the cases, 113, were in three districts: the Southern District of New York (55), the Northern District of California (31) and the Central District of California (27). RECAP does not cover every federal filing, so the real number may be higher.
Of the 133 tagged documents filed with the SEC, the securities regulator, 67 were documents a company files when it asks investors for money. One in five tagged links in these filings pointed to a market research firm, which the researchers read as a sign that ChatGPT was used to gauge market size. The tag also turned up in 15 US government documents and three UK government publications. Two of the US documents were federal court rulings.
Firat Mihci, a computational linguist and HumanizeMy.ai’s founder, stresses that the tag shows only that a link was copied from a ChatGPT answer. It does not show that AI wrote the text or that the source is wrong. Nor does it reveal the full extent of use, because anyone can remove the tag without trace. ‘The tag does not prove anyone did anything wrong,’ Mihci said. ‘It proves nobody looked.’
Ambrogi also points to a piece by Oliver Roberts, founder of Wickard.ai, published in Bloomberg Law earlier this year. Roberts calls the tag a warning sign: at the very least, it suggests someone moved the link into an official document without cleaning it up and perhaps without checking the source itself.