AI Aulis

AI NEWS IN ENGLISH · 19 November 2026

The most important AI news every morning. AI writes and checks the stories against the original sources – check important facts in the sources.

38 stories · next issue tomorrow morning · How the paper is made →

← Issue 19 November 2026Paper

German Federal Court of Justice: unchecked AI-drafted grounds can make an appeal invalid

AI-generated contentWritten by AI

heise.de · Source published: 18 November 2026 at 18:42 (UTC+02:00)

Grounds of appeal in a criminal case drafted with AI may be invalid if the lawyer does not check their content, Germany’s Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has said. In the case at hand, however, the court examined the appeal and dismissed it.

The BGH’s 3rd Criminal Senate set out its position in a decision issued on 13 October (case number 3StR 350/26), the German technology site heise online reported. The defendant had challenged a judgment of the Kaiserslautern Regional Court by way of a Revision, an appeal limited to points of law.

Under established case law on Section 345(2) of the German Code of Criminal Procedure, grounds for a Revision are valid only if defence counsel contributes to them in substance and takes full responsibility for them. The requirement protects the defendant’s interests. It also spares Revision courts improperly presented or poorly structured grounds.

The senate said defence counsel’s involvement may be lacking if the grounds are drafted with AI and the lawyer does not substantially oversee their content. The appeal may then even be rejected as inadmissible.

The judges’ doubts arose from the content of the text. The grounds contained general, seemingly standardised passages that bore hardly any relation to the judgment under appeal. For example, they discussed in general terms whether the offender could have withdrawn from the attempted offence. The lower court, however, had found that the offender could no longer affect the victim: the offender had fled into a storeroom and the police had already been called. The grounds did not address these findings.

Despite serious shortcomings, the senate considered the grounds just sufficient in this case. Doubts about the lawyer’s contribution were not enough to show that the lawyer had played no part at all. The BGH examined the Revision on its merits and dismissed it as unfounded. The decision therefore did not defeat this appeal because of the use of AI, nor does it ban AI.

The decision tells lawyers that unchecked AI text increases the risk of an appeal being rejected, heise online wrote. The site links the ruling to courts’ tougher stance. Appeal briefs have already contained fabricated case numbers and judgments, after which the Kammergericht in Berlin reminded lawyers of their duty to check.

Report an error in this story