Physicist says GPT-6 Astra helped draft a candidate lattice definition of the Standard Model
OpenAI has launched a science blog. In its first post, physicist Nathaniel Craig says GPT-6 Astra helped develop Craig’s idea into a candidate lattice definition of the Standard Model and took the lead in developing the detailed proof. The result is still under expert review.
OpenAI launched a science blog on 15 November, US time. The company said the blog will publish research results, examples of models being used in scientific work and researchers’ experiences. Posts will also explain how the work can be checked and where the method falls short.
In the first post, physicist Nathaniel Craig describes work that appeared as a preprint on arXiv in October. Craig prepared the preprint with the help of OpenAI’s GPT-6 Astra model. In it, Craig proposes a definition of the Standard Model that does not rely on perturbation theory.
The weak interaction makes a lattice definition difficult
The Standard Model describes the known elementary particles and three of the four fundamental interactions. Physicists usually calculate its predictions with perturbation theory: they first solve the case without interactions exactly, then add the interactions as small corrections. This approach cannot, for example, determine the mass of the proton. No definition of the full theory exists that does not rely on perturbation theory.
Lattice field theory replaces spacetime with a grid of points, or lattice. The theory can then be defined precisely and calculated on a computer. The method has worked in research on the strong interaction.
The weak interaction, however, acts differently on left- and right-handed fermions, such as quarks and electrons. When a left-handed fermion is put on a lattice using the most natural rules, an extra right-handed partner appears. So-called overlap fermions remove the extra partners. They do not, however, specify how to define the fermions’ phase, which depends on the fields at every point of the lattice. Physicist Martin Lüscher solved the problem for simpler theories, but for the Standard Model it has remained open for more than 25 years.
Craig says Astra took the lead on the proof
Craig’s idea was to represent the same fields on a succession of ever finer lattices. Comparing two consecutive lattices yields part of the phase correction, and summing the parts gives a rule for the original lattice. Craig said the proof shows that the rule gets the phase right when the fields are changed in an allowed way and returned to their starting state. The result holds at finite lattice spacing, and only if field strengths stay below a certain limit at the lattice scale.
In Craig’s account, Astra proposed a way to transfer the fields to finer lattices, showed that the comparisons converge and took the lead in developing the detailed proof. Lattice field theorists Maarten Golterman, Andreas Kronfeld and Yigal Shamir went through the proof and asked questions. Craig wrote that the questions increased the physicist’s confidence in the result.
Many questions remain open
Craig stresses that the definition is a candidate. Experts still need to assess whether it has all the desired properties. Craig said the method answers the question in principle but not yet in practice. Using it in realistic lattice simulations will require a lot of work.
Craig is now investigating whether the construction satisfies the reflection positivity condition at finite lattice spacing. The condition helps connect lattice calculations to a quantum theory in which probabilities are conserved. Nor does the construction define the theory in continuous spacetime. On this point, Craig refers to OpenAI’s own proof of the existence of Yang–Mills theory.
In the blog’s launch post, OpenAI also lists results. The company said its internal system produced a proof in September that addresses the Navier–Stokes existence and smoothness problem. It also said thousands of agents using the GPT-Rosalind model analysed data from earlier experiments on millions of mouse brain cells in 32 minutes. The work was done in collaboration with PerturbAI and Scripps Research.