AI Aulis

AI NEWS IN ENGLISH · 20 November 2026

The most important AI news every morning. AI writes and checks the stories against the original sources – check important facts in the sources.

41 stories · next issue tomorrow morning · How the paper is made →

← Issue 20 November 2026Paper

English High Court lets winning couple recover £1,488 AI subscription cost

AI-generated contentWritten by AI

legalfutures.co.uk, solicitorsjournal.com, judiciary.uk, info-gov.uk, dailyaibrief.com · 5 sources · Sources published: 19–20 November 2026

Two pensioners who represented themselves will recover the cost of an AI legal research service from the other side. The judge assessed the cost on ordinary costs principles and stressed that AI costs are not automatically recoverable.

Mr Justice Sweeting of the High Court of England and Wales gave a costs ruling on 19 November in Foster & Anor v Wargrave on Thames Housing Association Ltd [2026] EWHC 3000 (KB). The court’s press summary describes it as the first decision on when the cost of an AI research tool can be recovered as litigation costs.

Linda Foster and Richard Hitchens are pensioners in their seventies who ran their case without a lawyer. They won an appeal against a suspended possession order that the housing association Wargrave on Thames had obtained over how an electricity charge in their tenancy agreement should be read. The couple paid £124 a month for the tool for a year and borrowed the money from Hitchens’s brother, Info-Gov.uk reported. They said they used the tool to search for case law and to prepare their written submissions.

The judge rejected the couple’s main argument that the subscription was a payment for legal services. CPR 46.5, the Civil Procedure Rule on costs for litigants in person, uses legal services to mean services provided by or under the supervision of a lawyer. In the judge’s view, the subscription was a tool, like a legal database or textbook, that the couple used to do the work themselves.

Nor did the judge accept the housing association’s argument that the cost was an irrecoverable overhead. What mattered was whether the cost had been incurred for this particular litigation and whether it was reasonable and proportionate. The judge said electronic disclosure and document management platforms, for example, had been assessed in the same way. ‘The technology itself neither renders the expenditure automatically recoverable nor automatically irrecoverable,’ he said, as quoted by Info-Gov.uk.

Legal Futures reported that the judge considered it would be odd if lawyers could use their AI resources while litigants in person were, in effect, unable to use similar tools.

The facts of the case decided the award. The couple did not use a general-purpose or free large language model but bought a specialist legal service specifically for this litigation. The judge said their written and oral submissions were careful and succeeded on the main issue. He warned that prolix and unhelpful AI-generated material is likely to lead to costs being disallowed.

The judge cut the couple’s other claims. They were allowed £5,600 for 649 hours of their own work, about 40 per cent of the sum claimed, Solicitors Journal reported.

‘The technology may be new, but the principles governing recoverability are not,’ Sweeting said.

Report an error in this story