Logician says Claude found 663 theorems in Kurt Gödel’s notebooks
Jan von Plato gave Claude his transcriptions of Kurt Gödel’s notebooks. He said the model wrote a 650-page explanation of them within days and extracted 663 theorems, of which about 400 passed checking in Coq as stated.
The Guardian reported on 13 November that researchers have begun using AI to interpret Kurt Gödel’s unpublished notes. The report is based on an interview with the project’s leader. Ua.news and mezha.net have summarised the Guardian’s article.
Finnish logician Jan von Plato has led a project at the University of Helsinki since 2017 that studies 16 notebooks the Austrian logician Gödel kept in the early 1940s. They contain 1,009 pages of mathematics and logic. Much of the text is written in Gabelsberger, a German shorthand that was obsolete even in Gödel’s time. Working out the mathematical meaning progressed at about a page a week.
The model read transcriptions, not shorthand
In September, von Plato gave Claude his own transcriptions of the notebooks, six books he had written on Gödel and other research literature. People, not the model, turned the shorthand into text.
Within a few days, Claude wrote a 650-page explanation of the whole material. Von Plato said the explanation had to be checked page by page, but that no human could do the same work: AI can connect all the pieces in a thousand pages of material, he said. He also said the notebooks anticipate dozens of results that became known only in the 1970s and 1980s, and contain 14 topics in logic that have not been studied. This rests on Claude’s assessment, von Plato said.
Coq accepted about 400 theorems as stated
Von Plato asked Claude to extract the theorems for which Gödel had a proof, a sketch of a proof or an idea for a proof. Claude found 663. They were checked with Coq, a proof assistant: a program that checks a formally written proof step by step.
About 400 theorems were verified as stated, von Plato said. About 200 were repaired, for example by making the statement more precise or adding an assumption, and about 50 turned out to be false. He said this is no surprise, as Gödel himself sometimes wrote falsch! (‘wrong’) in the margins of his notes. The figures come from von Plato.
The independence proof was one step short
Von Plato’s first task for Claude was to find out whether the notebooks contained a proof of the independence of the axiom of choice. A statement is independent if it can be neither proved nor disproved within an axiom system. Paul Cohen received the Fields Medal in 1966 for showing that the axiom of choice and the continuum hypothesis are independent. Gödel said he had proved the result in the 1940s but could not reconstruct the proof from his notes.
Claude’s answer was: almost. Von Plato said Gödel got one definition wrong, although he had written the correct definition two years earlier. Von Plato checked the proof Claude reconstructed with Coq, and it passed.
Joel David Hamkins, professor of logic at the University of Notre Dame, has not seen the reconstruction. He said that if it holds, it would be significant and historically interesting, but historians must establish how much of it is Claude’s work and how much Gödel’s. In his view, the similarities with Cohen’s proof show that Gödel was on the right track, but not that Gödel had a proof.